The Eve Original Mattress and the Nectar Memory Foam Mattress are both all-foam designs with a medium-firm feel, so choosing between them comes down to value and range rather than how they're built.
These two are closer than most head-to-heads. Both are five-layer, all-foam mattresses with a medium-firm feel, both have a seven-zone base designed to ease pressure from shoulders and hips, and both come with a cooling-focused top cover and a non-slip base. Lie on either and you'll get a similar experience: level support with a cushioned surface that lets you settle in rather than sink.
Because the builds are so alike, the deciding factor is what you pay and what you get around the mattress. The Nectar Memory Foam Mattress wins this comparison. It sits comfortably below the typical price for a foam mattress of this kind, where the Eve Original sits well above it, and Nectar backs its mattress with a 365-night manufacturer trial.
That said, the Eve isn't without its own case. It comes in nine sizes to Nectar's five, and it carries a Which? Best Buy badge, so if you need an unusual size it stays firmly in the running.
Our verdict at a glance: which mattress wins?
The Nectar gives you an equivalent five-layer, zoned foam construction at well below the typical memory foam price, where the Eve costs considerably more than average.
WINNER
You need a size Nectar doesn't make
The Eve Original comes in nine sizes, from UK Single up to Emperor plus EU sizes, against five for the Nectar, so odd bed frames are better served here.
You want independent backing
The Eve carries a Which? Best Buy certification, which is reassurance from an independent tester rather than the brand itself.
You like a lightly cushioned surface
Eve describes the feel as medium-firm support with a lightly cushioned top, which means a soft first impression while the denser base holds your spine level.
RUNNER UP
It's the far better value of the two
The Nectar sits below the typical price for a memory foam mattress, while the Eve sits at more than double that benchmark, so you're getting a very similar construction for considerably less.
You get a full year to decide
Nectar's 365-night manufacturer trial is a long stretch to test a mattress at home, and the 10-year guarantee matches Eve's.
Hot sleepers get specific help
The cover carries MTick certification for menopause-friendly cooling, and the open-cell foam beneath it encourages airflow, which means the classic memory foam hug with less of the clamminess older foam designs were known for.
Eve Original
Nectar
Firmness
Medium Firm
Medium Firm
Layers
5
5
Trial (nights)
200
365
Guarantee (years)
10
10
Price Range
£599 to £899
On construction, there's genuinely little between them. Both are five-layer all-foam builds with a seven-zone supportive base, a breathable comfort layer, contouring memory foam and a non-slip bottom layer. The Nectar states a 25cm depth and CertiPUR certified foams, while the Eve leans on its springy evecomfort layer for a slightly livelier top feel. Neither design gives you a reason to pick one over the other.
Construction verdict: which wins on build?
On construction, there's genuinely little between them. Both are five-layer all-foam builds with a seven-zone supportive base, a breathable comfort layer, contouring memory foam and a non-slip bottom layer. The Nectar states a 25cm depth and CertiPUR certified foams, while the Eve leans on its springy evecomfort layer for a slightly livelier top feel. Neither design gives you a reason to pick one over the other.
Which mattress feels better?
<p>Both mattresses sit in the same firmness territory. Nectar rates its mattress a medium-firm 6.5 out of 10, a level that suits most back and combination sleepers, giving enough give for your shoulders and hips while keeping your spine level. Eve describes the Original as medium-firm support with a lightly cushioned feel, so the surface feels a touch softer on first contact even though the support underneath is comparable.</p><p>Side sleepers are looked after by both: the Eve's base layer has seven contour zones cut in to relieve pressure from shoulders and hips, and the Nectar pairs pressure-relieving memory foam with a seven-zone base for the same job. If you like a properly firm, unyielding surface, though, neither is ideal, and Eve's cushioned top in particular may feel a little too soft for you.</p>
Other important factors to consider before buying.
Beyond feel, the practical terms deserve a look before you buy. Eve gives you a 200-night trial and a 10-year guarantee, while Nectar offers a 365-night manufacturer trial with a 10-year guarantee of its own. The table below sets both out side by side.
Eve Original
Nectar
Trial (nights)
200
365
Guarantee (years)
10
10
Do bear in mind that as these mattresses come delivered in sealed boxes they will have a rubbery smell when first extracted. They need a good few hours in a room with the windows open before you sleep on them.
Environmental impact and sustainability
Eve Original
Nectar
Certifications
CertiPUR
Prices for both mattresses update daily in the tables below. As a rule, the Nectar comes in noticeably lower than the Eve for a comparable size.
Eve Original Mattress
The Nectar Memory Foam Mattress is the winner here, and value is the reason. These two mattresses are remarkably similar in construction: five foam layers each, seven-zone bases, cooling covers, medium-firm support. When the builds are this close, price and terms decide it, and the Nectar sits below the typical cost of a memory foam mattress while the Eve sits well above it. Nectar also gives you a 365-night trial to test that decision at home, and its foams carry CertiPUR certification with an MTick badge for cooling. The Eve Original remains a good mattress, and if you need one of its nine sizes or value its Which? Best Buy status, it's a defensible pick. For most buyers, though, the Nectar delivers the same style of sleep for less.
Decision helper
Consider your primary need: the widest choice of sizes with independent Which? backing, or a near-identical foam feel at a much friendlier price with a full year to trial it.
WINNER
You need a size Nectar doesn't make
The Eve Original comes in nine sizes, from UK Single up to Emperor plus EU sizes, against five for the Nectar, so odd bed frames are better served here.
You want independent backing
The Eve carries a Which? Best Buy certification, which is reassurance from an independent tester rather than the brand itself.
You like a lightly cushioned surface
Eve describes the feel as medium-firm support with a lightly cushioned top, which means a soft first impression while the denser base holds your spine level.
RUNNER UP
It's the far better value of the two
The Nectar sits below the typical price for a memory foam mattress, while the Eve sits at more than double that benchmark, so you're getting a very similar construction for considerably less.
You get a full year to decide
Nectar's 365-night manufacturer trial is a long stretch to test a mattress at home, and the 10-year guarantee matches Eve's.
Hot sleepers get specific help
The cover carries MTick certification for menopause-friendly cooling, and the open-cell foam beneath it encourages airflow, which means the classic memory foam hug with less of the clamminess older foam designs were known for.
Is the Nectar mattress better than the Eve Original?
For most buyers, yes. The two builds are very similar, five foam layers with seven-zone bases and cooling covers, but the Nectar costs noticeably less relative to typical memory foam prices and comes with a 365-night trial. The Eve pulls ahead only if you need one of its nine sizes or want its Which? Best Buy certification.
Which is firmer, the Eve Original or the Nectar?
They're close. Nectar rates its mattress a medium-firm 6.5 out of 10, while Eve describes medium-firm support with a lightly cushioned feel, so the Eve may feel slightly softer on the surface. Underneath, both provide zoned support designed to keep your spine level, and neither suits someone wanting a very firm, unyielding bed.
Do the Eve Original and Nectar mattresses sleep hot?
Both are all-foam designs with cooling measures built in, though foam generally holds more warmth than springs. The Eve has a moisture-wicking cover and breathable evecomfort foam, while the Nectar has a cooling cover with MTick certification and open-cell foam for airflow. Very hot sleepers may still prefer a sprung or hybrid alternative to either.
Which has the better trial, Eve or Nectar?
Nectar's trial is longer at 365 nights, against 200 nights for the Eve Original. Both come with a 10-year guarantee. In practice, either trial gives you months to decide at home, so the difference matters most if you're a cautious buyer who wants the longest possible window to return the mattress.
Is the Eve Original worth the extra money over the Nectar?
Only in specific cases. The Eve costs well above the typical memory foam price while the Nectar sits below it, and the constructions are very similar. The extra spend buys you nine sizes rather than five, including Emperor and EU options, plus Which? Best Buy backing. If neither of those matters to you, the Nectar is the sensible buy.
Author
Jo Plumridge
Author